Parabolic SAR fliplong
Resultados de Backtest @ SPY β€’ Daily

Curva de Equidad

El backtest cubre 32.5 years de datos SPY β€’ Daily (SPDR S&P 500), desde January 29, 1993 hasta July 31, 2025.

La curva de equidad es el rendimiento de la estrategia a lo largo del tiempo. Debes compararla con el rendimiento de Compra y MantΓ©n del activo. En general, quieres que el Γ‘rea azul estΓ© bien por encima del Γ‘rea gris.

El drawdown es cuΓ‘ntas pΓ©rdidas (realizadas o no realizadas) ha tenido la estrategia si se compara con el pico mΓ‘s alto de equidad. Compara esto con el drawdown del activo para ver si tu estrategia hace un trabajo decente de aislarte de la volatilidad bajista. En general, el Γ‘rea roja debe estar bien dentro del Γ‘rea gris.

Curva de Equidad
Estrategia
Activo
Drawdown de Estrategia
Drawdown de Activo

Entonces, hemos hecho backtest de Parabolic SAR flip en 32.5 years de velas SPY β€’ Daily.Β Este backtest resultΓ³ en 392 posiciones, con una tasa de ganancia promedio de 47% y una relaciΓ³n riesgo-recompensa de 1.39.Β Si asumes que la relaciΓ³n riesgo-recompensa de 1.39 se mantiene, necesitas una tasa de ganancia mΓ­nima de 41.8 para ser rentable. AsΓ­ que vas bien hasta ahora.Β Las mΓ©tricas clave son las siguientes:

  1. Retorno Total: Retorno Total: 117.10% vs 1354.30% para el activo
  2. MΓ‘ximo Drawdown: MΓ‘ximo Drawdown: -48.30% vs -56.70% para el activo
  3. ExposiciΓ³n: ExposiciΓ³n: 64.60% tiempo en el mercado
  4. Tasa de Ganancia: Tasa de Ganancia: 47.0%, vs 41.8% mΓ­nimo
  5. RelaciΓ³n Riesgo/Recompensa: RelaciΓ³n Riesgo/Recompensa: 1.39

Con esa exposiciΓ³n en mente, puedes ver que para 65% tiempo-en-mercado, obtienes 8.65% del potencial alcista del activo, y 85.19% del potencial bajista del activo.

Parabolic SAR flip: entrar en una posiciΓ³n cuando

All of the following: # India
  D Parabolic SAR (0.02, 0.02, 0.2, 0) < D Chart(close)

Parabolic SAR flip: salir de una posiciΓ³n cuando

Exits as soon as None of the entry conditions are true any more.

Parabolic SAR flip @ SPY β€’ Daily (117.1%) explicado por Alex C, Mike, Sarah

Alex C

Autor

The strategy shows some interesting statistical properties, but I am not completely convinced it is ready for real trading yet. Let me explain why.

The good parts first: The Risk/Reward ratio of 1.39 combined with the 47% win rate gives us a positive expectancy of 0.1, which is mathematically viable. The win rate leeway of 46.58% above the minimal required win rate is quite healthy and provides good statistical buffer. Also worth noting is that the strategy achieves this with relatively low market exposure of 64.6%, which could be interpreted as risk-reducing.

However, there are serious concerns: The total return of 117.1% over 32.5 years is significantly below the buy & hold return of 1354.3%. This is problematic since we want to beat the market, not underperform it massively. The Sharpe ratio of 0.16 is extremely low - anything below 1.0 is considered poor, and we want to see atleast 1.5 for a robust strategy. The maximum drawdown of -48.3% is also quite high and could be difficult to stomach in real trading situations.

I would suggest to either modify the strategy parameters to improve the risk-adjusted returns, or consider developing a completely new approach. The mathematical foundation is there, but the real-world application needs significant optimization.

Mike

Autor

Yo fam, let me break down this Parabolic SAR strategy on SPY! πŸš€

This backtest is giving me mixed vibes tbh. The win rate is sitting at 47% with a solid 1.39 risk/reward ratio - that's actually not bad at all! What's really juicy is that win rate leeway of 46.58%, meaning we've got plenty of cushion above the minimum needed win rate. That's some serious safety margin right there! πŸ’ͺ

But here's where it gets a bit sus - the overall net profit is 117% over 32.5 years, while buy & hold crushed it with 1354%. The max drawdown of -48.3% is pretty scary too ngl. The market exposure at 64.6% means we're sitting out quite a bit of the action, which might explain why we're lagging behind buy & hold so much. The recent performance looks better though - that 21.1% in 3 months is kinda fire! πŸ“ˆ

Overall, I'd say this strategy could be decent for swing trading if you're cool with the slower pace (only 2 trades per month on average). It's not gonna make us Lambo money, but it's got some solid risk management features. Might be worth experimenting with adding some extra confirmation signals to boost that win rate a bit higher. Just my two cents from behind the Wendy's counter! πŸ”

Sarah

Autor

Madre mΓ­a, this strategy is a complete disaster! You would have been better off putting your money under your mattress than trading this nonsense.

Let's look at the embarassing facts: A pathetic 117% return over 32.5 years while buy & hold made 1354%? That's not just underperformance - that's financial suicide! You're basically paying fees and taking risks to earn less than a savings account. The market exposure of 64.6% shows you're missing out on major moves while still getting hit with the drawdowns.

The win rate is below 50% which would be acceptable if your winners were significantly bigger than your losers. But no - your risk/reward is barely above 1.3! That's like playing Russian roulette with 5 bullets instead of 1. The max drawdown of 48.3% is also horrible - almost as bad as holding through a crash but with none of the recovery benefits.

The only slightly positive thing I can say is that your win rate leeway is decent, but that's like complementing someone's shoelaces while their house is on fire. This strategy needs to be completely scrapped or majorly overhauled. Anyone trading this live deserves to lose their money.

MΓ©tricas tabulares de Parabolic SAR flip sometido a backtest en SPY β€’ Daily

Total de Operaciones392Beneficio Neto117.1%Beneficio Compra y MantΓ©n1354.3%
Tasa de Ganancia47%Ratio Riesgo/Recompensa1.39MΓ‘ximo Drawdown-48.3%
MΓ‘ximo Drawdown del Activo-56.7%ExposiciΓ³n64.6%Promedio de Velas en PosiciΓ³n12.5
Ratio de Sharpe0.16Ratio de Sortino0.47Volatilidad Realizada11.00%
Racha MΓ‘xima de Ganancia7Racha Promedio de Ganancia1.8Racha MΓ‘xima de PΓ©rdida8
Racha Promedio de PΓ©rdida2.0Promedio de Operaciones por Mes2.0Promedio de Operaciones por DΓ­a0.1
Desv. Est. del Retorno3.4Desv. Est. de la PΓ©rdida2.0Desv. Est. de la Ganancia2.6
Expectativa0.1Beta0.42

Todos los backtests para Parabolic SAR flip

common.strategyexposiciΓ³nrendimiento vs activodrawdown vs activotasa de gananciarecompensa/ riesgo
BTCUSDT β€’ 1 Minute
55%(-2.7%/0.5%) -5.40x(-3.4%/-4.4%) 0.77x361.5
EURUSD β€’ 1 Minute
55%(-1.7%/-2.7%) 0.63x(-1.9%/-3.3%) 0.58x371.3
GLD β€’ 1 Minute
56%(-4.4%/-0.9%) 4.89x(-4.9%/-4.8%) 1.02x411.1
NVDA β€’ 1 Minute
56%(11.3%/20.6%) 0.55x(-3.2%/-5.3%) 0.60x402.0
PLTR β€’ 1 Minute
56%(-4.0%/10.4%) -0.38x(-8.6%/-12.9%) 0.67x381.5
SPY β€’ 1 Minute
58%(1.4%/4.0%) 0.35x(-2.0%/-1.5%) 1.33x411.6
TSLA β€’ 1 Minute
55%(-5.0%/-9.9%) 0.51x(-11.0%/-15.9%) 0.69x381.5
WMT β€’ 1 Minute
55%(-0.8%/-0.7%) 1.14x(-2.9%/-5.1%) 0.57x371.6
BTCUSDT β€’ 10 Minutes
57%(3.2%/4.7%) 0.68x(-10.6%/-11.7%) 0.91x391.6
EURUSD β€’ 10 Minutes
56%(-1.3%/0.6%) -2.17x(-2.3%/-3.6%) 0.64x401.4
GLD β€’ 10 Minutes
57%(22.1%/37.4%) 0.59x(-8.4%/-8.3%) 1.01x461.6
NVDA β€’ 10 Minutes
58%(24.3%/45.0%) 0.54x(-28.0%/-42.8%) 0.65x441.4
PLTR β€’ 10 Minutes
60%(121.1%/459.2%) 0.26x(-45.7%/-46.5%) 0.98x471.5
SPY β€’ 10 Minutes
59%(7.9%/14.1%) 0.56x(-16.1%/-20.7%) 0.78x441.4
TSLA β€’ 10 Minutes
56%(86.8%/24.4%) 3.56x(-30.8%/-55.3%) 0.56x431.7
WMT β€’ 10 Minutes
58%(37.0%/38.7%) 0.96x(-12.4%/-23.8%) 0.52x451.7
BTCUSDT β€’ 1 Hour
55%(40.1%/65.5%) 0.61x(-25.5%/-30.6%) 0.83x421.6
EURUSD β€’ 1 Hour
55%(-3.2%/3.5%) -0.91x(-7.5%/-9.0%) 0.83x391.5
GLD β€’ 1 Hour
55%(61.4%/118.5%) 0.52x(-21.7%/-22.2%) 0.98x431.8
NVDA β€’ 1 Hour
58%(1284.1%/3304.6%) 0.39x(-42.2%/-68.0%) 0.62x471.8
PLTR β€’ 1 Hour
55%(538.0%/1459.0%) 0.37x(-77.3%/-86.6%) 0.89x422.0
SPY β€’ 1 Hour
61%(70.4%/104.7%) 0.67x(-14.9%/-35.1%) 0.42x451.6
TSLA β€’ 1 Hour
56%(5558.2%/1240.0%) 4.48x(-40.4%/-75.1%) 0.54x442.4
WMT β€’ 1 Hour
57%(100.4%/142.7%) 0.70x(-18.3%/-26.9%) 0.68x431.8
BTCUSDT β€’ Daily
57%(379.6%/1339.3%) 0.28x(-68.0%/-76.6%) 0.89x432.3
EURUSD β€’ Daily
55%(-1.5%/8.0%) -0.19x(-17.8%/-23.3%) 0.76x371.7
GLD β€’ Daily
57%(301.4%/585.6%) 0.51x(-23.7%/-45.3%) 0.52x461.9
NVDA β€’ Daily
59%(14739.3%/417479.9%) 0.04x(-76.5%/-90.0%) 0.85x462.0
PLTR β€’ Daily
57%(559.1%/1476.3%) 0.38x(-50.4%/-84.9%) 0.59x492.7
SPY β€’ Daily
65%(117.1%/1354.3%) 0.09x(-48.3%/-56.7%) 0.85x471.4
TSLA β€’ Daily
57%(440.9%/25131.3%) 0.02x(-75.3%/-75.0%) 1.00x372.6
WMT β€’ Daily
59%(476.7%/10620.7%) 0.04x(-60.7%/-50.6%) 1.20x451.6